There are plenty of opportunities to enjoy good pizza in Portland. And the newest addition is Pizzaiolo, making New York style pizza with a Bronx accent. Newly opened on Cumberland Avenue, next to a few dicey convenience stores—hardly of the carriage-trade ilk— it’s also across from the Preble Street Teen Center and the wonderful Schulte and Herr, Portland’s only German restaurant. Urban archeologists might term this as a neighborhood in transition. I wouldn’t hold my breath. Still, I stopped in for a slice earlier in the week and ordered two pies from Pizzaiolo just last night.
Overall, Portland has a lot of pizza options for such a small city. Bill’s Pizza on Commercial Street is probably the best example here of ersatz Italian-American pizza. I haven’t been there in a few years (and its under new management since my last visit) but I remember it being eminently forgettable.
At the other end are the gourmet pizzas made by Portland’s reigning pizza purveyors and chefs. From Slab’s truly artisanal wedge-style pizza; the thin-crust slices from the ever-expanding Otto, virtually a mini-conglomerate of our local pie set; farm-to-table wood-oven baked Flatbread Company and to the carefully tended pies at Bonobo’s-these have been the premier spots to enjoy pizza with pizazz. Portland’s restaurants shouldn’t be overlooked either. Many are baked in wood ovens to emerge thin- crusted and crisp. The Grill Room, for instance, has fancy-topped 9-inch pies baked in a wood oven.
A slice ($3.50), the Porko, with sausage, mozzarella, sausage, meatballs and tomato sauce at Pizzaiolo
For the casual slice on the go or on the rare occasion when I’ve ordered it for delivery, I think Leonardo’s on Forest Avenue is pretty good-classic Italian-American pizza that’s made with wholesome ingredients such as King Arthur Flour. It’s really a variation on New York style pizza, which is basically a thin-crust pie loaded with tomato sauce and cheese.




















